About Us

Here for you.

Rummell-Brill is an independent insurance agency based in Plain City for over 70 years. To best serve our customers, we represent a select list of insurance companies, to offer you customized coverage solutions that give you peace of mind. Finding you the best solution to protect your home, business, farm, and life, it’s what drives us.

Free Insurance Quote

When considering whether you should compare your insurance, ask yourself the following. If catastrophe struck, do you have confidence your policy could replace your valuables?  If you are unable to work, is there a plan for income?  Could you be made whole if you suffered loss or damage to your farm, or other income-producing business?

These questions shouldn’t cause fear or unease. Our free quote provides the basis for a comprehensive insurance strategy customized for your personal or business goals. Insurance protection provides you peace of mind, so that you can dream confidently.

Business Philosophy

Transparency reinforces integrity. Our doors are always open to you. Whether you are filing a claim, purchasing new or additional coverage, or just need to talk through something, at Rummell-Brill, we are happy to see you.

“Do the right thing. Do the best you can do.

Treat others the way you want to be treated.”

Lou Holtz

Let us work for you.

We do the research, find the solutions to fit your unique situation, and explain it in a way that gives you confidence. We love the nuances of saving you money while creating a crafted insurance experience.

Build relationships.

Rummell-Brill has lasted 3 generations for one reason: we take care of our relationships. As you change, so do your insurance needs. As your agents, we promise to evolve with you, insuring you properly every step of the way.

Customer Service, A Family Tradition

The agency founder, Joe Rummell, first opened our door to friends and neighbors in 1948. His mother, Daisy Sharpe, worked with Joe until she retired at the age of 82. Joe’s wife, Wanda Rummell, worked in the agency from 1967 until 2015. Joe formed a partnership with his daughter Jenny Rummell-Brill in 1977. In 1982 Joe’s son-in-law Brian Brill joined the partnership: now with more than 40 years of experience, Jenny Rummell-Brill and her daughter Roselynn Cassady carry on the family tradition of honest, reliable service.

The team at Rummell-Brill is dedicated to customer service and satisfaction.

You are Number 1

We shine when life throws you shade. After an incident, our entire team is committed to making you whole. And to ensure we’re constantly improving, we follow up after we’ve taken care of your claim, to see if there were any opportunities for us to better serve you. If you have any suggestions that would make us better, let us know HERE.